Recently I was asked by an aspiring Non-Executive Director (NED) whether previously being a director of a business that failed a decade ago was going to hamper his chances of becoming a NED? I can recount numerous similar conversations with those who were concerned about their appointability because of: bankruptcy, time out of the workforce, career gaps, political stoushes, sackings, bankruptcies or even a scattered work history.
If any of these reasons are preventing you from developing a board career, the good news is that illegality or being barred from acting as a Director aside, these ‘blips’ or ‘career gaps’ rarely impact appointability if handled properly.
Here’s what I suggest when addressing blips or gaps in your career
Focus on what they need – not what they expect
Whether you have a ‘clean’ work history or have ‘blips’ or ‘career gaps’ you must recognise that any organisation appointing a new director to their board is going to be fearful of making a mistake and will be risk-averse.
Gaps/Blips in particular produce this fear and perceived risk. This is important because it is not the blip that is the problem but rather the fear it produces. As such, it is essential that you de-risk your appointment and “dare them not to appoint you“. To do that you should focus on dissipating the appointing organisation’s fears – not filling the gap – an important difference.
Taking this approach is the first step to overcoming any objections appointing bodies might have about you.
Do not ignore it
To do this effectively my first piece of advice is to not ignore it. If you have a blip, address it head-on. It is going to come out sooner rather than later – in fact, your assumption should be that they know already. If you don’t address it then rightly or wrongly it will be assumed that you are hiding something. And, that something is almost certainly be envisaged to be worse than the reality – for example, the gap in your work history is because you went to jail for fraud when in reality you took off a couple of years to care for a sick relative.
Prepare for the question
When answering the gap/blip question avoid unclear or vague answers that may create an impression that you have something to hide. Own the decision, it was yours to make and you made it. And, if it wasn’t yours to make say so.
Don’t spin it
But, don’t try to make it into something it isn’t. If it was a failed business don’t try to spin the awful experience into something an experience that is valuable to the board. Perhaps some of what you experienced was valuable but it will rarely be seen that way. Or if it is they probably feel like they already know it or someone without a blip could offer the same knowledge.
Do a reality check
Know that gaps or blips are rarely as big a deal as you think they are. I think people expect that other people expect them to be perfect. They are not. Never are. Never will be. But I also believe that candidates expect themselves to be perfect and if they don’t fit the ‘perfect’ mould they will never be appointed. This simply isn’t true. There is no such thing as a perfect candidate. Yes, appointing bodies do prefer someone who can “walk on water”’ but when they can’t find that person they happily settle for a human – blips and all.
Focus on what you do offer
Appointing organisations quickly reset their expectations and focus on what they need in a successful candidate – as opposed to what the candidate doesn’t have. This is what you should focus on. Your value. This is what you must be able to articulate in your board profile. You must demonstrate that your experience, your skills and your passion far outweigh any concerns they may have.
Do this to ‘dare them not to appoint you’ – blips and all
Develop relationships that will back you. A recent study found that the recommendation of one board member counts more than meeting all the appointment criteria that a board is looking for. So this is where you should focus your attention.
Become a known candidate by getting to know the organisation personally, the board members, past board members, their clients and partners – anyone and everyone connected with the organisation you would like to be appointed to. Not only will this level of research and connectedness alleviate any fear that might be connected to your ‘blips’ it also unlocks the 80% of board opportunities that are never advertised or go through a formal recruitment process. It is also exactly what we teach our Executive Members to do.
Remember you don’t need to be perfect
Boards don’t need perfect. What they need is comfort – their fears relieved. By focusing on the things you have done, can do and developing authentic relationships your gaps will cease to be an issue.
About the Author
David Schwarz is CEO & Founder of Board Appointments – The UK’s leading board advertising and non-executive career support firm. He has over a decade of experience of putting people on boards as an international headhunter and a non-executive recruiter and has interviewed over one thousand non-executives and placed hundreds into some of the most significant public, private and NFP roles in the world.